The success of Nintendo is founded on a reputation of controlling each and every aspect of its output. It creates and manufactures its own consoles, which are mainly bought to play in-house Nintendo titles. Such complete dominance is rare in both technology and media; maybe only giants like Disney or Apple compare.
Yet, a prominent property exists as a notable exception. Pokémon is possibly Nintendo's biggest property. Some estimates, albeit difficult to verify, suggest it is the highest-grossing media franchise in history. This fortune flows from ubiquitous merchandise, video game sales, and a booming card game business. But interestingly, Pokémon is not wholly Nintendo's property.
The core Pokémon video games are released exclusively on Nintendo consoles, but they are made by the external developer Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the entity behind the card game), Nintendo co-owns The Pokémon Company. This organization oversees the global merchandising business that generates multibillions. Furthermore, the massive hit Pokémon Go was created and published by external studios under a license from The Pokémon Company, operating at a considerable remove from Nintendo's immediate oversight.
A Precedent of Outside Inspiration
For a corporation famous for its strict processes, this partnership seems inconsistent. Yet, Pokémon was not the first instance an outside title drove Nintendo's fortunes.
In 1989, Nintendo released the groundbreaking Game Boy. But, its in-house teams had not yet found the ideal application for it. The solution came from outside: Tetris. Nintendo's determined quest to secure the rights for the Game Boy version of Tetris is legendary in the gaming industry. Tetris enabled Nintendo to establish and rule the portable gaming market for years to come. This portable division offered vital stability during difficult times for its console operations and eventually culminated in the versatile Switch.
The Birth of a Phenomenon
While Nintendo created brilliant portable iterations of Mario and Zelda, a truly original concept for a definitive portable experience eluded its top creators. Instead, that inspiration originated with ex- writer Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. After learning that Game Boys could be connected via a Link Cable, he imagined trading digital beings, drawing from his youthful memories of collecting insects.
Nintendo recognized the potential in the pitch from Game Freak and gave it the green light. However, it took a long time for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the sprawling role-playing game released in 1996. Another couple of years went by before the games, alongside a trading card game and an anime, burst into a worldwide craze. Pokémon extended the lifespan of the Game Boy well into its 14-year run and essentially guaranteed Nintendo's financial security.
Why Not Buy It All?
It may appear strange that Nintendo did not move to fully acquire Game Freak and Pokémon once its massive success became clear. This is precisely the kind of action a corporation like Disney would have made. Instead, the tripartite partnership between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was established as early as 1998. This evolved into The Pokémon Company, which now manages the global franchise.
Nintendo has a tradition of tight-knit, enduring relationships with chosen independent developers, such as HAL Laboratory and Intelligent Systems, yet buying them. But, Pokémon's success was unprecedented. So why not seize the whole pie? It is likely that creators Satoshi Tajiri and Tsunekazu Ishihara were never prepared to sell their brainchild. It is also possible that Nintendo's executives, from the formidable Hiroshi Yamauchi to the astute Satoru Iwata, took a conscious decision not to seek complete acquisition.
The Advantages of Distance
In hindsight, this setup may have been remarkably shrewd. It is difficult to imagine Nintendo, with its meticulous approach to brand control, allowing the relentless merchandising blitz that characterized Pokémania. The Pokémon Company, operating with a measure of autonomy, could execute a voracious plan to claim global mindshare and spending.
This distance allowed Nintendo to reap the financial rewards while remaining somewhat shielded from the periodic controversies related to the brand. When panic arose about the card game's impact, the focus was directed elsewhere from Nintendo. Also, the sometimes variable quality of recent Game Freak games is a reputational cost mostly carried by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo directly.
A Enduring Partnership
Maybe this distinct relationship with Pokémon is quintessentially Nintendo in the end. The company is renowned for not fixing what works.|Nintendo generally eschews unnecessary